Search for Cheap Deals on5 Star Hotels in Shelter Island
You choose what matters — star rating, location, amenities.
We pick the perfect hotel, packed with all your must-haves.
Your hotel is revealed right after booking, and you save up to 60%!
Featured 5 Star Shelter Island Hotels
![Mill House Inn](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/3000000/2870000/2861900/2861838/e8287d67_y.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=420&h=224&q=medium)
![Casa Newmark Holiday home 7 BestStayz.1](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/33000000/32420000/32411100/32411044/6850db1b_y.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=420&h=224&q=medium)
5-Star Hotel in Shelter Island
It’s time. No more meh motels and so-so stays. This vacation it’s all about living it up, and that starts with a great hotel. You want first-class service and award-winning restaurants. Well, let us introduce you to a 5-star hotel in Shelter Island.
So nice you’ll blink twice
What makes a hotel worthy of supreme star-age? For starters, the service has to be top-notch and personalized. These hotels often have 24-hour room service, a welcome gift upon your arrival, and help you with your bags—even if you travel light.
Are they nicer? Heck yeah, they are! Most 5-star hotels have jaw-dropping aesthetics that give an authentic feel of class. And we’re not talking about that faux-gold soap dish your Aunt Tilda puts out for the guests—it’s the real deal.
Stars in your eyes
Are 5-stars hotels worth it? If you like the finer things in life, then yes, they sure are. But we also know you’re the type that likes to get your caviar on a fish stick budget. We’re right there with you, and that is why we make it easy to find the best 5-star hotel in Shelter Island for you. Sort by:
-
Price: Want to live large, but keep that budget balanced? We got you. We have 5-star hotels starting at $508.
-
Amenities: Shelter Island skyline view? Maybe a heated indoor pool? Looking for a Michelin-star restaurant? Search for the hotels that have the amenities you desire.
-
Hotwire Hot Rate: We’ll tell you the name of the hotel after you book, and you might just save a ton.
When you’re looking for the top 5-star hotels in Shelter Island—but don’t want to pay top dollar—let us help you out. You can get that posh palace of your dreams, and have money left to take on Shelter Island your way.
More Hotel Options in Shelter Island
Top Attractions in Shelter Island
- Hotels near Gardiner's Bay Country Club (1.79 mi)
- Hotels near Shelter Island Historical Society (0.48 mi)
- Hotels near Mashomack Preserve (1.33 mi)
- Hotels near Shell Beach (1.76 mi)
- Hotels near Shelter Island Whale's Tail (0.65 mi)
- Hotels near Wades Beach (1.32 mi)
- Hotels near Havens House (0.49 mi)
- Hotels near Ocean Beach Park (20.68 mi)
- Hotels near Cooper's Beach (14.57 mi)
- Hotels near Essex Steam Train (19.88 mi)
- Hotels near Hammonasset Beach State Park (17.98 mi)
- Hotels near East Hampton Main Beach (11.47 mi)
- Hotels near Wolffer Estates Vineyard (9.08 mi)
- Hotels near Sag Harbor Marine Park (5.14 mi)
- Hotels near Orient Point County Park (8.1 mi)
- Hotels near Hither Hills State Park (16.92 mi)
- Hotels near Connecticut River (51.06 mi)
- Hotels near Ditch Plains Beach (21.94 mi)
- Hotels near Kontokosta Winery (3.52 mi)
- Hotels near Rocky Neck State Park (17.42 mi)
Nearby Cities
- Montauk Hotels (20.67 mi)
- Hamptons Hotels (9.46 mi)
- Long Island Hotels (45.79 mi)
- East Hampton Hotels (10.8 mi)
- Southampton Hotels (12.97 mi)
- Greenport Hotels (2.66 mi)
- Riverhead Hotels (19.82 mi)
- Old Saybrook Hotels (15.93 mi)
- Sag Harbor Hotels (5.41 mi)
- Hampton Bays Hotels (16.62 mi)
- New London Hotels (23.42 mi)
- Westbrook Hotels (16.09 mi)
Recommended cities for you
- Las Vegas Hotels
- New York Hotels
- Orlando Hotels
- Los Angeles Hotels
- Miami Hotels
- San Francisco Hotels
- New Orleans Hotels
- Chicago Hotels
- Fort Lauderdale Hotels
- Boston Hotels
- Honolulu Hotels
- San Diego Hotels
- Washington Hotels
- Toronto Hotels
- Anaheim Hotels
- Atlanta Hotels
- Nashville Hotels
- Seattle Hotels
- Phoenix Hotels
- Myrtle Beach Hotels
Car Rentals Near Shelter Island
- Car rentals in Montauk
- Car rentals in Hamptons
- Car rentals in Long Island
- Car rentals in East Hampton
- Car rentals in Southampton
- Car rentals in Greenport
- Car rentals in Riverhead
- Car rentals in Old Saybrook
- Car rentals in Sag Harbor
- Car rentals in Hampton Bays
- Car rentals in New London
- Car rentals in Westbrook
- Car rentals in Amagansett
- Car rentals in Madison
- Car rentals in Niantic
- Car rentals in Southold