Cheap Rental Car Deals in Shelter Island
24/7 Customer Service
Enjoy modest savings*
Low price guarantee
Hot Rate® Car rentals in Shelter Island
Today's top deal
Midsize
Standard
Premium pickup
Midsize SUV
Compact SUV
Standard Pickup truck
Standard SUV
Special Car
Hot Rate® Sedan Car rentals in Shelter Island
Today's top deal
Midsize
Standard
Special Car
Premium
Hot Rate® SUV Car rentals in Shelter Island
Today's top deal
Compact SUV
Standard SUV
Full Size SUV
Premium SUV
More rental deals in Shelter Island
Special Car
Economy
Compact
Midsize
Alamo Car Rentals in Shelter Island
Economy
Compact
Midsize
Standard
Shelter Island Car Rentals
You’re finally heading to Shelter Island and you have your list of underground spots that have yet to make the “best of” roundups. But unless you want to live and die by the bus schedule or hope the ride shares are fast and frequent, your best bet is having your own set of wheels. You can score a cheap Shelter Island rental car through Hotwire and still have plenty leftover cash to cut across town to that restaurant your friend won’t stop talking about. Better yet, ditch the trendy restaurant and cruise around to find a hidden hot spot that isn’t on everyone’s social feed…at least not yet.
Grab your wheels and go
It’s not about the freedom of the open road, it’s about the liberty to make your vacation what you want. Imagining the wind in your hair as you fly down the highway? Book a convertible. Maybe you want to take the road not taken (or paved)—hop in an SUV. Perhaps, this is the trip where you live it up and a luxury car sets the tone. But if you want this vacation to be full of pleasant surprises, then choose a Hotwire Hot Rate car. You’ll find out the rental agency after you book, but we only work with the best car rental agencies in Shelter Island, so there’s no risk in rolling these dice.
Trunk full of choices
Maybe it’s all about the make or model. Could be you just want the best rate possible. The car you select is up to you, and so is the way you pick your ride. Filter by:
- Rate: We have Shelter Island rent-a cars starting at $8.99
- Car Rental Brand: Choose your wheels from rental car suppliers
- Car Type: Compact? Minivan? SUV? Luxury? Your ride, your choice
- Hotwire Hot Rate Car: You pick the location and car type, let us choose the car rental agency to get you the best value
What’s better than the low price you get on your car? Picturing all the new spots you’ll discover. And if you book a Hotwire Hot Rate car, you can go even more places with the money you saved. Book here at Hotwire to grab the best deals on car rentals in Shelter Island before your next trip.
Frequently Asked Questions About Shelter Island
How can I get a cheap rental car in Shelter Island last minute?
You can always find great last minute deals on car rentals in Shelter Island. Save big with Hot Rate - score exclusive, unbeatable deals from our car suppliers.
Which car rental companies are at the Shelter Island airport?
Shelter Island offers a variety of car rental companies. Add your favorite airport to your search to see all available car companies.
Why should I book a last minute car rental with Hotwire?
When you need a last minute car rental deal, Hotwire's daily Hot Rate deals allows you to easily compare exclusive discounts from a wide range of the most popular car rental companies.
What if I have to cancel my trip to Shelter Island?
The fastest path to canceling your booking is through one of our self-serve tools found at https://vacation.hotwire.com/lp/coronavirus-travel
- Popular Car Rental Deals by Destination
- Popular Car Suppliers
- Car Rentals Near Top National Parks
- Popular Airport Car Rentals
- Top Nearby Airport Car Rentals
- Top Package Deals
- Flight + Hotel Packages For Popular Attractions
- Cross Country Flight + Package Deals
Car Rental Deals in Shelter Island
- Car rentals in Las Vegas
- Car rentals in New York
- Car rentals in Orlando
- Car rentals in London
- Car rentals in Paris
- Car rentals in Cancun
- Car rentals in Miami
- Car rentals in Los Angeles
- Car rentals in Rome
- Car rentals in Punta Cana
- Car rentals in Riviera Maya
- Car rentals in Barcelona
- Car rentals in San Francisco
- Car rentals in San Diego County
- Car rentals in Oahu
- Car rentals in Chicago
Popular Airport Car Rental Destinations in Shelter Island
- Dallas-Fort Worth International Airport (DFW)
- Boston Logan Airport (BOS)
- Cincinnati-Northern Kentucky International Airport (CVG)
- Denver International Airport (DEN)
- Hartsfield-Jackson Airport (ATL)
- Las Vegas McCarran Intl Airport (LAS)
- Dulles Airport (IAD)
- Los Angeles International Airport (LAX)
- John F. Kennedy International Airport (JFK)
- La Guardia Airport (LGA)
- O'Hare International Airport (ORD)
- Philadelphia Airport (PHL)
- Minneapolis-St. Paul International Airport (MSP)
- Orlando Airport (MCO)
- Portland International Airport (PDX)
- New Orleans Airport (MSY)
- SeaTac Airport (SEA)
- Sky Harbor Airport (PHX)
- Toronto Airport (YYZ)
- San Francisco International Airport (SFO)
Nearby Airport Car Rentals in Shelter Island
- Car rentals at LaGuardia Airport (LGA)
- Car rentals at Stewart Intl. Airport (SWF)
- Car rentals at John F. Kennedy Intl. Airport (JFK)
- Car rentals at Newark Liberty Intl. Airport Airport (EWR)
- Car rentals at Montauk Airport (MTP)
- Car rentals at Brookhaven Calabro Airport (WSH)
- Car rentals at Elizabeth Field Airport (FID)
- Car rentals at Groton - New London Airport (GON)
- Car rentals at Tweed - New Haven Regional Airport (HVN)
- Car rentals at Westerly State Airport (WST)
Packages In and Around New York
Flight + Hotel Packages to Shelter Island's Most Popular Tourist Attractions
- Shelter Island Historical Society Vacations
- Mashomack Preserve Vacations
- Shelter Island Whale's Tail Vacations
- Shell Beach Vacations
- Gardiner's Bay Country Club Vacations
- Havens House Vacations
- Wades Beach Vacations
- Ocean Beach Park Vacations
- Cooper's Beach Vacations
- East Hampton Main Beach Vacations
Flight + Hotel to Destinations across the Country
Car Rental Locations of Shelter Island
- Car rentals in Montauk
- Car rentals in Long Island
- Car rentals in New England
- Car rentals in Hamptons
- Car rentals in Riverhead
- Car rentals in Bridgehampton
- Car rentals in East Hampton
- Car rentals in Southampton
- Car rentals in Greenport
- Car rentals in Old Saybrook
- Car rentals in New London
- Car rentals in Sag Harbor
- Car rentals in Westbrook
- Car rentals in Hampton Bays
- Car rentals in Amagansett
- Car rentals in Madison
- Car rentals in Southold
- Car rentals in Niantic
- Car rentals in Old Lyme
- Car rentals in Westhampton Beach
- Car rentals in Water Mill
- Car rentals in Calverton
- Car rentals in Clinton
- Car rentals in Coastal Connecticut
- Car rentals in Essex
- Car rentals in Waterford
- Car rentals in Mattituck
- Car rentals in North Fork
- Car rentals in Village of East Hampton
- Car rentals in Village of Southampton
- Car rentals in Shelter Island Heights
- Car rentals in Cutchogue
- Car rentals in Sagaponack
- Car rentals in East Quogue
- Car rentals in Quogue
- Car rentals in East Lyme
- Car rentals in Springs
- Car rentals in Wainscott
- Car rentals in Ivoryton
- Car rentals in Orient Point
Top Shelter Island Hotels
- Quality Inn Old Saybrook - Westbrook
- Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa
- Montauk Manor
- Hyatt Place Long Island East End
- Saybrook Point Resort & Marina
- Water's Edge Resort & Spa
- Sound View Greenport
- Pier Blue Inn Old Saybrook - Essex
- The Harbor Front Inn
- Budget Host East End Hotel in Riverhead
- Baron's Cove
- The Bentley Hotel Southampton
Visiting Shelter Island
*Savings are based on actual Hot Rate® car rentals made from airport pick-up locations as compared with the lowest published rates found on leading retail travel sites. Prices are dynamic and vary based on the booking date and length of the car rental. There is no guarantee these savings or rates will be in effect at the time of your search. Availability is limited. Hot Rate® cars are different from retail rates. With Hot Rate® cars you enter the location, date, and car class. The car rental company is revealed only after booking. All bookings are final.