Cheap Rental Car Deals in Fire Island
24/7 Customer Service
Enjoy modest savings*
Low price guarantee
Hot Rate® Car rentals in Fire Island
Today's top deal
Compact
Hyundai Accent or similar
5 people
30% off
Price was $93 per day and is now $65 per day
$93*
$65
per day
Midsize
Toyota Corolla or similar
4 people
13% off
Price was $74 per day and is now $65 per day
$74*
$65
per day
Standard
Volkswagen Jetta or similar
5 people
14% off
Price was $76 per day and is now $66 per day
$76*
$66
per day
Full Size
Ford Fusion or similar
5 people
14% off
Price was $77 per day and is now $66 per day
$77*
$66
per day
Compact SUV
Ford Eco Sport or similar
5 people
30% off
Price was $95 per day and is now $67 per day
$95*
$67
per day
Midsize SUV
Toyota Rav4 or similar
5 people
14% off
Price was $78 per day and is now $67 per day
$78*
$67
per day
Standard SUV
Hyundai Santa Fe or similar
5 people
24% off
Price was $99 per day and is now $75 per day
$99*
$75
per day
Midsize Open Air all terrain
Jeep Wrangler 2 Door or similar
4 people
24% off
Price was $101 per day and is now $77 per day
$101*
$77
per day
Hot Rate® Sedan Car rentals in Fire Island
Today's top deal
Economy
Kia Rio or similar
4 people
12% off
Price was $71 per day and is now $63 per day
$71*
$63
per day
Compact
Hyundai Accent or similar
5 people
30% off
Price was $93 per day and is now $65 per day
$93*
$65
per day
Midsize
Toyota Corolla or similar
4 people
13% off
Price was $74 per day and is now $65 per day
$74*
$65
per day
Standard
Volkswagen Jetta or similar
5 people
14% off
Price was $76 per day and is now $66 per day
$76*
$66
per day
Hot Rate® SUV Car rentals in Fire Island
Today's top deal
Midsize SUV
Toyota Rav4 or similar
5 people
14% off
Price was $78 per day and is now $67 per day
$78*
$67
per day
Standard SUV
Hyundai Santa Fe or similar
5 people
24% off
Price was $99 per day and is now $75 per day
$99*
$75
per day
Midsize Open Air all terrain
Jeep Wrangler 2 Door or similar
4 people
24% off
Price was $101 per day and is now $77 per day
$101*
$77
per day
Full size Open Air all terrain
Jeep Wrangler Unlimited or similar
4 people
6% off
Price was $104 per day and is now $98 per day
$104*
$98
per day
More rental deals in Fire Island
Special Car
Compact or larger but priced like a compact or similar
4 people
Price is $69 per day
$69
per day
Compact
Hyundai Accent or similar
5 people
Price is $73 per day
$73
per day
Midsize
Toyota Corolla or similar
4 people
Price is $73 per day
$73
per day
Alamo Car Rentals in Fire Island
Minivan
Dodge Grand Caravan or similar
7 people
Price is $93 per day
$93
per day
Standard Pickup truck
Nissan Frontier or similar
4 people
Price is $94 per day
$94
per day
Compact SUV
Ford Eco Sport or similar
5 people
Price is $96 per day
$96
per day
- Popular Car Suppliers
- Car Rentals Near Top National Parks
- Popular Airport Car Rentals
- Top Nearby Airport Car Rentals
- Top Package Deals
- Flight + Hotel Packages For Popular Attractions
- Cross Country Flight + Package Deals
Popular Airport Car Rental Destinations in Fire Island
- Dallas-Fort Worth International Airport (DFW)
- Boston Logan Airport (BOS)
- Cincinnati-Northern Kentucky International Airport (CVG)
- Denver International Airport (DEN)
- Hartsfield-Jackson Airport (ATL)
- Las Vegas McCarran Intl Airport (LAS)
- Dulles Airport (IAD)
- Los Angeles International Airport (LAX)
- John F. Kennedy International Airport (JFK)
- La Guardia Airport (LGA)
- O'Hare International Airport (ORD)
- Philadelphia Airport (PHL)
- Minneapolis-St. Paul International Airport (MSP)
- Orlando Airport (MCO)
- Portland International Airport (PDX)
- New Orleans Airport (MSY)
- SeaTac Airport (SEA)
- Sky Harbor Airport (PHX)
- Toronto Airport (YYZ)
- San Francisco International Airport (SFO)
Nearby Airport Car Rentals in Fire Island
- Car rentals at LaGuardia Airport (LGA)
- Car rentals at Stewart Intl. Airport (SWF)
- Car rentals at John F. Kennedy Intl. Airport (JFK)
- Car rentals at Newark Liberty Intl. Airport Airport (EWR)
- Car rentals at Brookhaven Calabro Airport (WSH)
- Car rentals at Republic Airport (FRG)
- Car rentals at MacArthur Airport (ISP)
- Car rentals at East Hampton Airport (HTO)
- Car rentals at Francis S. Gabreski Airport (FOK)
Packages In and Around New York
Flight + Hotel Packages to Fire Island's Most Popular Tourist Attractions
- Ocean Beach Vacations
- Robert Moses Beach Vacations
- Fire Island Lighthouse Vacations
- Robert Moses Water Tower Vacations
- Robert Moses State Park Vacations
- Smith Point County Park Vacations
- TWA Flight 800 International Memorial Vacations
- Cherry Grove Community House and Theatre Vacations
- Sunken Forest Vacations
- Lighthouse Beach Vacations
